Brand Positioning: Establishing Category Membership
Categories serve as the foundation for thecompetition-based approachto positioning because they imply the goal that a consumer achieves by using a brand.
Referencing the example inyesterdays post, informing consumers that a brand has membership in the wine category tells them its purpose: it enhances the enjoyment of an elegant meal, and it promotes social relations. If consumers know the category, linking the brand to it quickly brings to mind the goal that is achieved by brand use; in other words, asking someone to have a glass of wine is an invitation to visit and to socialize.
In some instances, people may be unfamiliar with the category in which a brand holds membership. To address this issue, thepoints of parityassociated with the category, rather than the category label, can be used to convey the goal served by the brand. If people did not know the goals achieved by drinking wine, a frame of reference could be created by describing a brand as a beverage that contains alcohol, goes well with food, and is enjoyed in formal and casual social interactions. Points of parity can also serve to clarify the goal served by the brand when category membership alone is insufficient to do so. Indicating that Two Hands wine is an accompaniment to an elegant meal or is appreciated at special occasions informs people that it is a high-end brand, not an everyday one.
Alternatively, marketers may employexemplarsof a product category rather than the category label to signal the goal served by a brand. Exemplars are brands that are widely known for a particular benefit. In the mens designer clothing category, Adam Kimmel or Patrik Ervell may be unknown. But when they are placed in a context of famous American designers of mens clothing such as Calvin Klein, Perry Ellis, and Tommy Hilfiger, consumers are likely to make the connection that the Kimmel or Ervell brand serves the goal of wearing clothing with cutting-edge design.
When a new brand is introduced, consumers attempt to categorize it in a manner that helps them understand at least one goal that can be achieved by using it. This is easily done when the brand fits neatly into a familiar category, as would be the case for a new brand of wine or beer. Selecting a category becomes more challenging for innovative products. By definition, such brands do not neatly align with the points of parity associated with specific, existing categories. In response to this problem, it may be tempting to employ an abstract category and associated goal. However, this approach can be risky.
Consider TiVo, which pioneered the digital video recorder category. TiVos initial advertising merely told consumers that the brand empowered users to watch what they want when they want. Although this proposition was appealing (who wouldnt want such freedom), in the absence of more specific product categorization, consumers had difficulty grasping exactly what TiVo was and, therefore, how they might use it. A better strategy would have been to begin by relating TiVo to a familiar category such as VCRs, explaining that like a VCR, TiVo enabled the TV viewer to record shows for viewing at a later time. Against this backdrop, consumers could appreciate what made TiVo unique (i.e., the point of difference), such as easier searching and recording due to the on-screen TV guide listings. Once such a basic understanding of TiVo (and DVRs in general) was established, the more abstract goal of controlling ones entertainment could have been meaningfully introduced.
Whatever the means of representing the category, marketers must help consumers understand the goal in using a brandbeforeorconcurrent withthe presentation of information about why it is superior to alternatives with the same frame of reference. For example, when Apple introduced iPhone, it informed consumers that the brand was a communication devicebeforeit informed consumers about why it was superior to other brands. This category was evoked not only by the brand name, but also by comparing the iPhone to traditional phones in initial advertisements. Once people understood iPhones primary communication function, additional functions such as ease of Internet search and e-mailing were introduced to highlight its points of difference in relation to other phones.
In other situations, it is important to present both the category and point of difference concurrently. For example, when consumers use a search engine such as Google to find a product, they are likely to be making an on-the-spot decision about which site to click on. Thus, a clear representation of the brands category membership and point of difference in the Google listing will help consumers make this choice. Along these lines, FTD Flowers listing states send flowers, roses, gifts, gift baskets, and more with convenient local delivery. This identifies the specific categories in which the brand competes (flowers, gifts, baskets) as well as the point of difference (local delivery), and thus provides a basis for discriminating among the available alternatives. In contrast, when consumers land on s listing, they are only informed about its category membership (football, golf, apparel, exercise equipment) and not its point of difference, which invites them to consider also Dicks Sporting Goods or Sports Authority, or some other online sporting goods vendor.
The importance of choosing a competitive frame by identifying a category is illustrated by the recent launch of the Nano economy vehicle by Tata Motors of India. Nano was introduced at a base price of 100,000 rupees (U.S. $2,500), making it substantially cheaper than Maruit Udyog, which was priced at about $5,000 and had 50 percent share of the economy market. With a population of 1.1 billion and low penetration of the car category in India (12 car owners per thousand in the population versus 765 in the United States), there were at least two ways to frame the competition for Nano.One possibility was as a safe alternative to the motorbike (a ubiquitous mode of transportation in India). This categorization was likely to attract those who were at point of entry in the car market, such as college students.
Alternatively, Nano might be positioned as an economy car that provides superior customer value. Nano was inexpensive to purchase, and it was relatively fuel efficient, promising 52 mpg in the city and 61 mpg on the highway. It was also stylish and offered more seating room than the larger economy car and main competitor, the Maruti 800. Such an approach might appeal to families that already had cars but would be attracted to a vehicle that offered superior value. Thus, the choice of the motorbike category versus the economy car category as the competitive frame affects both the target customer and the brands point of difference.
Contributed to Branding Strategy Insider By:John Wiley & Sons, excerpted fromKellogg on Marketing, 2nd Editionby Alice M. Tybout (editor), Bobby J. Calder (editor), Phillip Kotler (foreword by) (c) 2010 by The Kellogg School of Marketing.
The Blake Project Can Help:The Brand Positioning Workshop
Branding Strategy Insider is a service ofThe Blake Project: A strategic brand consultancy specializing in Brand Research, Brand Strategy, Brand Licensing and Brand Education
FREE Publications And Resources For Marketers
Notify me of followup comments via e-mail
5 Keys To Brand Positioning Implementation
Confusing Brand Positioning With Brand Purpose
Brand Positioning For Competitive Advantage
Three Things A Strong Brand Positioning Must Do
How Did Apple Computer Get Its Brand Name?November 17th, 2011 • 3 Comments
21 Different Types Of BrandJanuary 27th, 2015 • 2 Comments
The Brand Brief Behind Nikes Just Do It CampaignAugust 06th, 2015 • 5 Comments
Brand Management: Process And ResponsibilitiesJanuary 30th, 2012 • 0 Comments
Color Psychology In MarketingJune 22nd, 2008 • 3 Comments
The Brand Growth Strategy WorkshopDecember 17th, 2018 • 0 Comments
How Brands Compete And WinDecember 12th, 2018 • 0 Comments
Brand Storytelling: Focus On People Not ProductsDecember 11th, 2018 • 0 Comments
How B2B Brands Succeed With Thought LeadershipDecember 10th, 2018 • 0 Comments
Why Brands Are Crucial To InnovationDecember 06th, 2018 • 0 Comments
Brand Management In The Age Of AIby Vishwa – November 16th, 2018 @ 02:06
5 Emerging Brand Trends For 2019by Bob Fast – November 13th, 2018 @ 01:10
5 Emerging Brand Trends For 2019by AJ – October 22nd, 2018 @ 13:57
Analyzing Nikes Controversial Just Do It Campaignby Michael Gold – September 6th, 2018 @ 16:39
Analyzing Nikes Controversial Just Do It Campaignby Jerome Conlon – September 6th, 2018 @ 13:06
and Stay Connected to BSISubscribe for email updatesSubmitSubscribers
If you find our thought pieces on brand strategy and brand management insightful and would like a deeper understanding for yourself, your marketing teams or leadership teams we can develop a customized learning engagement for you.
Brand education and training is a core competency ofThe Blake Project, the brand consultancy behind Branding Strategy Insider. As practitionersandeducators we deliver interactive brand education workshops designed to meet your specific learning objectives as well as align individuals and organizations with essential concepts in brand management, empowering them to release the full potential of their brands.
Breaking Free From Yesterdays Learning Format
With somber accuracy Futurist Alvin Toffler once predicted;The illiterate of the 21st century will not be those who cannot read and write, but those who cannot learn, unlearn, and relearn. Who among us represents todays illiterate? At the present pace of change, certainly more marketers than we can imagine. We are either part of the old or part of the new.
The relearning required for 21stcentury marketers is at the center of our approach to preparing marketers for brand leadership in an age of disruption.
Change is hard. Thats why the future can look so much like the past. And why brands and the marketers who manage them often lose their edge and a place in the future. For those organizations who see comfort zones as a dangerous place, we design unique learning experiences around your marketing teams most pressing topics. Learning experiences that challenge todays thinking about brands and brand management. That help prepare marketers for tomorrow. That break free from yesterdays learning format.
The Blake Project has trained thousands of marketers around the world at all levels of understanding and in all aspects of building brands. As thought leaders and brand education and training innovators we originated an immersive, competitive-learning format that considers all learning styles and challenges participants to solve real world marketing problems. Our approach is widely regarded as todays preferred learning method.
Featuring Brandingo: The Brand Management Safari, marketers compete and learn on teams in a fun, gamified format that infuses skill and chance and emphasizes participation over observation for memorable learning outcomes. We tap into the full expertise in the room and participants leave with a deeper perspective of the rapidly evolving disciplines of brand strategy and brand management (and/or other marketing topics) as well as actionable insights, tools and techniques for building strong brands.
As in your marketplace, some will win, some will lose, all will learn.
Further, for organizations seeking to educate and energize their employees in support of the brand we custom design and develop brand academies / brand centers of excellence which include live training and distance learning powered by i-STORY, our proprietary learning technology.
Abbott, Air France/KLM, Bayer, Bloomberg, Bombardier, Darden Restaurants (Olive Garden, Red Lobster et al), Equifax, GE, GlaxoSmithKlein, HP, Intel, Kawasaki, OgilvyRed, Monsanto, TD Ameritrade, T. Rowe Price, Unilever and Wyndham Worldwide are some of the organizations that have turned toThe Blake Projectfor help in meeting learning objectives.
Learning in a group environment boosts individual and team knowledge, refines processes, and provides an excellent team-building opportunity for your ntact The Blake Projectfor more on how we can prepare your marketers for the journey ahead.
Branding Strategy Insiderhelps marketing oriented leaders and professionals build strong brands. We focus on sharing thought provoking expertise that promotes an elevated conversation on brand strategy and brand management and fosters community among marketers. BSI is a service ofThe Blake Project, a leading brand consultancy based in the United States, serving marketers around the world.